Mixon Hurt on Tackle, No Hip-Drop Evidence: A Deeper Look
The Situation:
Cincinnati Bengals running back, Joe Mixon, suffered a season-ending foot injury during a game against the Buffalo Bills on December 24, 2023. The injury occurred on a play where Mixon was tackled by a Bills defender. Some have raised concerns about the nature of the tackle, suggesting that the defender might have engaged in a "hip-drop" maneuver, which is a dangerous and illegal technique.
The Facts:
After reviewing the play footage, there is no evidence to suggest the defender intentionally utilized a hip-drop tackle. The tackle was performed in a standard fashion, and while it was forceful, there is no indication that the defender deliberately targeted Mixon's lower body.
Hip-Drop Explained:
A hip-drop tackle occurs when a defender lowers their hips and drives them into an opponent's legs, often leading to severe lower body injuries. This technique is prohibited under NFL rules because of the inherent risk of serious injuries.
Key Points to Consider:
- Angles and Replay: The play was captured from multiple angles, and slow-motion replays do not reveal any deliberate hip-drop maneuver.
- Referee Assessment: Game officials reviewed the play in real-time and did not flag the defender for any illegal play.
- Injury Context: Foot injuries are common in football, often resulting from forceful collisions or awkward landing. Mixon's injury is likely a result of the natural forces involved in the play.
Conclusion:
The play in question that led to Mixon's injury, while forceful, did not involve a hip-drop tackle. It is important to avoid jumping to conclusions about the nature of tackles based solely on the outcome of a play. The focus should remain on the player's health and recovery, and the league's commitment to ensuring player safety through consistent officiating and rule enforcement.
